Frontdoor (American Home Shield) vs First American Home Warranty
Last verified: 2026-10-20
Frontdoor is a stand-alone company; First American’s is a segment of a title insurer. Both depend on renewals.
Frontdoor (American Home Shield)
UnscoredWins when: you want national coverage and the largest contractor network.
First American Home Warranty
UnscoredWins when: you live in one of its 36 states and close with First American.
Side by side
| Item | Frontdoor (American Home Shield) | First American Home Warranty |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 revenue | $2,093M | $442.9M |
| Profit measure | Net income $255M | Pretax income $86.5M (19.5% margin) |
| Claims cost | Cost of services $936M (45% of revenue, our arithmetic) | Claims 41.4% of premiums |
| Footprint | National, ~17,000 contractor firms | 36 states and DC |
| Real estate channel | $141M of revenue | Not split out |
Figures are from 2025 10-K and 20-F filings, state attorney general records, or the organization’s own pages where marked. Read 2026-10-20. Neither is scored.
Last verified 2026-10-20. Figures were re-read from the linked sources that day.
View changelog
- Comparison published.
Sources
- Frontdoor, Inc. Form 10-K for 2025 · accessed 2026-10-20
- First American Financial Form 10-K for 2025 · accessed 2026-10-20